Is Costco's Stock Overdue for a Big Rally?

Axe Cap view

Costco’s Rally Looks A Long Way Off

Strong sales but pricey shares keep Costco’s near-term upside capped.

Costco’s latest results show the kind of sales growth we love to see—11% net sales up and nearly 7% comparable store growth. For any retailer, that’s impressive, especially in a tricky consumer climate. Yet, the stock has only managed a modest 7% gain this year, lagging the broader market. The main reason? Costco’s shares trade at 45 times trailing earnings, a steep premium even for a high-quality operator. That multiple suggests a lot of the good news is already baked in, limiting room for a near-term rally. South African retail doesn’t offer a perfect playing field for comparison, but if we think about our local players—like Shoprite or Woolworths—they’re valued far more conservatively with better near-term catalysts. If the rand weakens sharply, we might see some volatility in imported goods retailers, but Costco itself feels far removed from immediate JSE moves. We’d say hold if you own it, but adding aggressively now looks unwise. The risk is that earnings disappoint or the US consumer stalls further, pushing the stock lower despite strong sales. this is just our opinion and not financial advice